[文法] 看到分词构句怎么判断是关系或对等子句

楼主: snob2 (ggg)   2016-11-22 22:43:51
请问,
看到分词构句怎么判断是从关系或对等子句减化而来
The girl, playing the piano, did not know it.
1 The girl, who was playing the piano, did not know it.
2 Playing the piano, the girl did not know it.
谢谢
作者: sunny1991225 (桑妮)   2016-11-22 22:56:00
第二个句子怎么样都不会简化成原PO问的那个句子吧第二个句子要变成分构也会是"The girl was playingthe piano, not knowing it."你现在新改出来的这个句子跟原本的句子意思则不一样因为通常把分构放在主句前,读者会觉得有一个隐藏的连接词,可能是解释the girl did not know it的原因(像是because she was playing piano),但原本的句子The girl, playing the piano, didnot know it并不会给读者这种理解。句子中那个分词词组playing the piano就只是插在句子中表达主词(the girl)的某种状态而且Playing the piano, the girl did not know it.不太像是从对等子句改过来的,因为对等子句改过来的分构通常会放在主句后面......
楼主: snob2 (ggg)   2016-11-23 08:41:00
主要是想问看到分词构句怎么判断是不是从关系子句减化来的例句只是举例, 谢谢

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com