[新闻] Alan Moore批评现代超级英雄片

楼主: lunashining (asdfgh)   2016-09-18 21:57:19
新闻网址:
http://www.cbr.com/alan-moore-criticizes-modern-superhero-stories-as-unhealthy-escapism/
简单来讲就是现代超级英雄电影漫画只是不健康的逃避主义
ALAN MOORE CRITICIZES MODERN SUPERHERO STORIES AS ‘UNHEALTHY ESCAPISM’
09.13.2016
by Dwight Hill
in Comic News
Comment
Alan Moore Criticizes Modern Superhero Stories as ‘Unhealthy Escapism’
Iconic comic book writer Alan Moore is widely regarded as one of the medium’
s greatest creators. His notable works — “Watchmen,” “V For Vendetta,”
and “Batman: The Killing Joke,” among many others — are widely regarded
as some of the best comics out there, often cited for influencing generations
of creators. However, Moore is known as an opinionated sort, having vocally
expressed his particular dissatisfactions with other creators and companies
he was formerly closely associated with.
During a recent interview with Vulture, the author addressed his issue with
modern comics, superheroics, and the growing adult audience.
RELATED: Alan Moore Confirms Retirement From Comic Books
After admitting that he no longer felt the same enthusiasm about writing
comics as he once did, Moore was asked about his feelings on the core of the
comic book audience. Moore responded that he believes the average reader age
is now 30-50 years old. This, the author believes, is a bad sign:
“People have been saying since the mid-’80s that ‘comics have grown up.’
I don’t think that’s factually true. I think what happened was that there
have been a couple of comics that seemed to be reaching for a more mature
readership, and that has coincided with the emotional age of the mass
audience coming the other way.”
Specifically addressing modern superhero movies, and the lasting power of
iconic Marvel and DC characters, Moore added:
“What are these movies doing other than entertaining us with stories and
characters that were meant to entertain the 12-year-old boys of 50 years ago?
Are we supposed to somehow embody these characters? That’s ridiculous. They
are not characters that can possibly exist in the real world. Yes, I did
Watchmen. Yes, I did Marvelman. These are two big seminal superhero works, I
guess. But remember: Both of them are critical of the idea of superheroes.
They weren’t meant to be a reinvigoration of the genre.”
RELATED: Ennis & Braun Take “Sixpack and Dogwelder” on an Alan
Moore-Inspired Road Trip
Moore summed up his argument against the current state of superhero comics,
simply calling them “unhealthy escapism”:
“The superheroes of my youth had dogs that dressed in capes and masks! It’s
obvious they stand for nothing other than the power of the imagination. I
tend to see a lot of these current figures as the focus of a kind of
unhealthy escapism…I can understand the desire to hang on to your childhood
but, it turns out, you can’t. There’s nothing wrong with having fond
thoughts about this or that but you don’t have to carry it with you your
whole life like some sort of suit of magic armor.”
As the author himself put it, he seems to be in a “really bad mood about
superheroes.”
作者: pttnowash (不用洗)   2016-09-18 21:58:00
english no good, angry SHI !!!
作者: LVE (强尼屁股)   2016-09-18 21:59:00
在电影版呛英雄,讨嘘吧
作者: lolic (lolic)   2016-09-18 21:59:00
哪个小咖 没听过
作者: lpb (Θ_Θ)   2016-09-18 22:01:00
上面说他小咖?XDDDDDD
作者: GAIEGAIE (该该)   2016-09-18 22:01:00
守护者和V怪客不算现代吗XD
作者: jojoSpirit (JoJoSpirit)   2016-09-18 22:07:00
无聊,去吃大便当吧,废文
作者: qn123456 (Q.N.)   2016-09-18 22:10:00
他里面有说呀,他的作品就算碰触到超级英雄题材也是在批判超级英雄的概念
作者: yangyx (爱吃hunny的pooh)   2016-09-18 22:11:00
他本人好像不太认同V怪客电影吧 觉得电影曲解他的本意
作者: qn123456 (Q.N.)   2016-09-18 22:12:00
他本人跟好莱坞关系很差,一来跟他的创作坚持有关(漫画的表现手法很难转译到其他媒体),二来是真的被那些改编计画搞过好几次了,没记错的话,当年V怪客剧组还擅自对外表示这改编电影是作者本人背书过的,害他老人家超级不爽
作者: kizuki0315 (C.诺斯)   2016-09-18 22:18:00
找Brittany Robertson吧
作者: shengchiu303 (Sheng)   2016-09-18 22:28:00
有人说他是小咖 快笑xDD
作者: RushMonkey (无脑猴)   2016-09-18 22:49:00
图像小说拿到雨果奖的作者 被说成小咖....基本上A爷没有一个他原作改编的电影 他认同的即便被称作最有诚意 最接近原作的守护者 他也是没认同过...
作者: lym0715 (暱称)   2016-09-18 22:51:00
说小咖是反串吧
作者: RushMonkey (无脑猴)   2016-09-18 22:53:00
而且V怪客电影版以原作来看 简直魔改 然后制作方又宣称他老人家有同意 肯定暴怒的
作者: guardian128 (伊莉莎白欧森是我老婆)   2016-09-18 23:30:00
哼哼
作者: boreguy (无聊男子)   2016-09-18 23:55:00
新警察XDDDDD
作者: zxc246812 (汤姆上校)   2016-09-19 00:17:00
说小咖是反串吗?..是认真的话我快笑死哈哈哈
作者: heavendemon   2016-09-19 00:18:00
蛮有逻辑的阿 所以应该学迪士尼 要弄出老少皆宜的剧
作者: catmeat777 (多萝喵)   2016-09-19 00:22:00
守护者剧情超好看阿~改编超级英雄电影神作
作者: chungyiju (海-绵-宝-宝)   2016-09-19 00:34:00
作者: redzon (and so it is)   2016-09-19 08:19:00
我超爱V怪客电影的 小说更好看吗?
作者: sellgd (李先生)   2016-09-19 08:55:00
看到尾 还是看不出他在抱怨什么 反正他作品比较非大众
作者: RushMonkey (无脑猴)   2016-09-19 10:08:00
V怪客 原作是图文小说 表达形式接近漫画(其实跟漫画没差多少 但加上艾伦莫尔独特的写作方式 几乎每一页的文字量跟资讯量都满多的)至于好不好看 原作的对自由 革命 追寻的精神跟探讨比电影深刻很多不过原作是1988年的作品 所以画风跟分镜很有时代感能接受就能好好享受他的剧情起伏
作者: octopus4406 (章鱼仔)   2016-09-19 10:33:00
他对主流电影感觉都相当有意见
作者: tsming (断水流大师兄)   2016-09-19 11:52:00
守护者和V怪客是我评价最高的超级英雄电影耶@@;
作者: ILLwill (illwill)   2016-09-19 13:32:00
守护者那部资讯量太大了,分乘三部电影是不是比较好?
作者: cheric (Respect)   2016-09-20 02:51:00
职业:巫师

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com