1956年设奖，1956~1966国联、美联不分开，全联盟只颁一名
以下列表两联盟分设赛扬奖后，当年得奖者的队伍有参与世界大赛
但我没有详细查是否有同场对决
1967 - (BOS)Jim Lonborg
1968 - (STL)Bob Gibson vs (DET)Denny McLain
G1 G4都是Gibson胜 McLain败，G4 Gibson有轰全垒打，苦主是救援投手Sparma
G7 红雀还是派Gibson先发，老虎没派McLain先发
Gibson3战都完投9局 只败最后一场
1969 - (NYM)Tom Seaver vs (BAL)Mike Cuellar 注 Denny McLain并列美联赛扬奖
G1-Cuellar胜Seaver败 G4-Seaver胜
两人赢的那场都是完投胜
1973 - (NYM)Tom Seaver
1974 - (LAD)Mike Marshall vs (OAK)Catfish Hunter
G1 两人都上场救援第九局
1977 - (NYY)Sparky Lyle
1978 - (NYY)Ron Guidry
1979 - (BAL)Mike Flanagan
1980 - (PHI)Steve Carlton
1981 - (LAD)Fernando Valenzuela
1982 - (MIL)Pete Vuckovich 注 1982~1997酿酒人在美联
1983 - (PHI)John Denny
1984 - (DET)Willie Hernandez
1985 - (KCR)Bret Saberhagen
1986 - (BOS)Roger Clemens
1988 - (LAD)Orel Hershiser
1990 - (OAK)Bob Welch
1991 - (ATL)Tom Glavine
1995 - (ATL)Greg Maddux
1996 - (ATL)John Smoltz
2001 - (ARI)Randy Johnson vs (NYY)Roger Clemens
没有对上，G7 RJ8局上场救援 Clements先发7局