[分享] Denis Villeneuve谈论漫威电影

楼主: mashmabo (马修范恩SUCK)   2021-09-17 11:18:58
之前马丁史柯西斯说漫威电影不是电影的一番言论,引发喧然大波
忙着宣传沙丘的Denis Villeneuve,接受法国媒体Premiere采访,也被问到对漫威的看法
“The problem today… Well, if we’re talking about Marvel, the thing is, all
these films are made from the same mold. Some filmmakers can add a little
color to it, but they’re all cast in the same factory. It doesn’t take
anything away from the movies, but they are formatted.” the director told
Premiere about his impression of the MCU.
时至今日的问题是,当我们讨论漫威,所有电影都好像是同一模具制造出来的
有些电影导演可以为它增添一些不同色彩,但它们都是在同一工厂生产的,而且公式化
导演告诉Premier,关于他对漫威电影的印象
The filmmaker said the same thing to the Spanish outlet El Mundo, perhaps a
little bit harsher. “There are too many Marvel movies that are nothing more
than a cut and paste of others,” he said.
导演也告诉西班牙媒体El Mundo同样的事,或许更刺耳一点,"太多漫威电影就好像剪接
其它电影,然后复制贴上"
https://0rz.tw/vd8nb 完整原文(THE PLAYLIST)
“Perhaps the problem is that we are in front of too many Marvel movies that
are nothing more than a ‘cut and paste’ of others,” Villeneuve said. “
Perhaps these types of movies have turned us into zombies a bit… But big and
expensive movies of great value there are many today. I don’t feel capable
of being pessimistic at all.”
"或许问题是太多漫威电影就好像剪接其它电影,然后复制贴上",Villeneuve说道
"也许这类型电影已经让我们变得有点像僵尸一样.."
但还是有许多巨大且昂贵的电影具有价值,我认为还不到悲观的时候
Villeneuve went on to say, “Just think of the golden age of Hollywood to see
that commercial films can make a different artistic proposal and, therefore,
political. I have never felt like a loss or an impediment to have a generous
budget to do what I wanted to do. Upside down. Who said that a movie on a big
budget can’t be artistically relevant at the same time? I am currently
thinking of people like Christopher Nolan or Alfonso Cuarón.”
Villeneuve继续说道,"想想好莱坞的黄金时代,商业电影可以做出不同的艺术表现,
甚至具有政治性的,我从不觉得有着慷慨预算去做我想做的,会是一种损失或阻碍
谁说大成本电影就无法同时具有艺术性?
我脑中目前就能想出克里斯多福诺兰跟艾方索柯朗
https://0rz.tw/zVIz3 完整原文(IndieWire)
While this might be another case of a well-respected director being critical
of the MCU, Villeneuve isn’t wholly against the Marvel machine. In a
separate director’s round-table with Harpers Bazaar, Villeneuve was part of
a panel with Academy Award winner Chloe Zhao who is currently directing The
Eternals for Marvel.
There, Villeneuve praised Zhao’s hiring as “genius,” telling Zhao, “I’m
your biggest fan. I think it’s genius that Marvel approached you because you
’re the radical opposite of it aesthetically.” Villeneuve praised Zhao’s
The Rider and how after watching it, he wrote Zhao “an artistic love letter”
for her ability to capture life on camera.
虽然可能又是批评漫威宇宙的另一位受尊敬的导演案例,但Villeneuve也不是全然反对
漫威到底,在与Harpers Bazaar的导演会议上,Villeneuve跟奥斯卡赢家赵婷一同参加
了小组座谈,赵婷目前执导漫威永恒族
Villeneuve盛赞赵婷是天才,告诉赵婷"我是妳的大粉丝"
我想漫威接触妳真是个天才之举,因为妳的美学风格跟漫威截然不同
Villeneuve也称赞赵婷的重生骑士,并且在观看后,写了一封唯美的信给赵婷
以赞扬她在镜头中捕捉生活的能力
Villeneuve’s comments about cut-and-paste Marvel movie have been criticized
on social media, most notably by Doctor Strange director Scott Derrickson,
who resurfaced a tweet he made defending his Marvel work when Scorsese
initially made his comments.
Villeneuve的言论在社群媒体上引发讨论,奇异博士导演Scott Derrickson
就在推特上,为自己漫威作品辩护
“As a director I don’t slag on the work of other directors even when I don’
t like something they’ve made. This job is hard enough for all of us, and
nobody ever sets out to make a bad movie,” Derrickson wrote.
Derrickson写道:
"作为导演,我不会批评其他导演的作品,即便他们做的某些事我不喜欢
这份工作对我们所有人来说已经够难了,没有人想拍烂电影"
https://0rz.tw/hqjeg 完整原文(IGN)
PS:Denis Villeneuve 你好敢讲阿,噗
作者: electronicyi (電子益)   2021-09-17 11:20:00
我在想那些说漫威公式化的 真的每一部都有看吗而且奇怪的是他称赞赵婷截然不同 但还没上映欸漫威电影宇宙其实第三阶段开始就很多新尝试了称得上公式化的也就奇异博士跟惊奇队长吧
作者: zitoneverwin (东山鸡头)   2021-09-17 11:42:00
完了 得罪漫威粉 还敢发来漫威板
作者: pineapple824 (凤梨〃)   2021-09-17 11:54:00
奇异博士是真的超级难看啊。
作者: electronicyi (電子益)   2021-09-17 12:07:00
东尼史塔克就MCU里面的科技神棍担当,不用太意外
作者: YuenYang5566   2021-09-17 12:08:00
重点是漫威被吐后会不会改啊 许多艺术电影也公式化
作者: littlejackbr (liljb)   2021-09-17 12:19:00
笑死,有票房的电影就有价值啦,还不懂吗,食古不化

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com