Re: [问卦] 为什么台湾吃狗肉会被骂

楼主: arrenwu (键盘的战鬼)   2015-11-11 00:14:12
※ 引述《oasisrose (life goes on)》之铭言:
: 这位大大,你假议题假议题的讲,结果你引用外国例子的论述根本乱讲啊
: 美国、瑞士是禁止贩卖狗肉的耶
: 跟台湾一样禁卖不禁吃耶
台湾是禁宰,这在美国会被当作是禁吃的地方
: 而且美国可吃狗的州,有更严格的附加条款,你也没提啊
: 除了不可公开贩售外,你私人屠宰给自己吃还得要有执照才行,不然最多可罚四年监禁
: https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20120108223033AAWdzjf
: It is illegal to sell meat for human consumption in the US
: unless the animal was inspected while alive and slaughtered
: at a licensed USDA abbatoir under licensed supervision.
: Such places are not allowed to accept animals not considered
: to be raised for human food, and most facilities specialize in one or
: two species; a cattle facility will probably not accept birds
: because they require different handling.
:
: Several US states have banned the slaughter and consumption of dogs
: completely.
: However there are numerous states in which dogs can be used for personal
: consumption provided they are killed in a humane way.
: All 50 states have banned the sale of dog meat to the general public and
: its use in public resturants,However those laws do not apply to American
: Indian reservations,Several of the Native American tribes still consume do
不是我想找碴,是我真的觉得你可能误会了原文的意思。
尤其是你之前说“那44个可以吃狗肉的州里面其实只有印地安人bhalbha”
印度安人所拥有的特权是“可以贩卖狗肉”
你给的这些文章内容,都没有讲到自己宰杀狗肉要有执照(license),
倒是有讲到要卖狗肉要经过特殊监控。
(虽然你引个奇摩知识家的结果,看起来也毛毛的 不过没关系)
我之所以会去质疑这个“需要有执照才能宰狗吃”的原因是因为,
如果真的觉得让人民吃狗肉ok,这要求不太合理。
作者: contrav (魂斗罗V)   2015-11-11 00:18:00
其实合理 因为宰猪牛也是要执照的
作者: skeric (寶寶剛)   2015-11-11 00:19:00
看到一堆狗本崩溃快笑死
作者: oasisrose (life goes on)   2015-11-11 01:06:00
你找不到licensed这个字?你原先文章提的是美国可直接私下宰狗、完全不受约束但事实上有很多附加条款
楼主: arrenwu (键盘的战鬼)   2015-11-11 01:13:00
那个 licensed 是跟营利用狗肉才有关啊
作者: oasisrose (life goes on)   2015-11-11 01:37:00
personal consumption是卖狗肉还是私用?
楼主: arrenwu (键盘的战鬼)   2015-11-11 01:39:00
Personal consumption 没有 licensed 需求啊

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com