Re: [请益] 快被外国老师搞混了 求教Argument Essay写作

楼主: dropguy   2019-04-20 11:48:07
※ 引述《D122 (小黑球)》之铭言:
: 如题 小弟最近在外国读语言学校
: 虽然是语言的不同 文法 用词习惯让我写英文文章一直受到挫折
: 但最近写Argument Essay一直跟老师有疑惑的点对不上
: 以下是小弟目前草稿
: Gender Topless Equality
: Have you ever thought that it is strange that only men can be topless?
: In
: fact, the attitudes toward women’s bodies are still conservative. For
: example, social media, like Instagram, prohibits any pictures with women’s
: nipples, but Instagram requires “every” user to wear clothes. In 2015, Adda
: Smardottir, a student, held the activity “Free the nipple”. She argued with
: the unfair standard of social media. In short, currently, some people still
: cannot accept topless women, but actually, bare breasts are not as bad as
: most people think, and this argument can be made on three sides, gender
: equality, social media, and patriarchy.
: Gender topless equality is really a part of gender equality. In our
: daily
: life, women always wear bras and cover their breasts. Some people think that
: it is common, while some people think that it is illogical. Steinfeld (2017)
: claimed that women have totally different opinions to whether they can show
: their breasts. These differences depend on how they were born and grew up.
: Most of all, it is true that attitudes toward genders, especially when
: topless, are not equality. However, Steinfeld (2017) showed that in some
: cultures around the world, like aboriginal communities, women go topless to
: this day. Hence, topless women might not be bad as some people think, and not
: every person can not accept topless women. Actually, male and female breasts
: are similar in composition, and breasts are just parts of people, but society
: just rejects women’s breasts. It is unreasonable, and the right of topless
: really belongs to women. Only when women really have the right to decide
: whether they show their breasts, Gender equality will exist.
: In social media, pictures with topless women are not allowed to be
: posted.
: Wheeling (2015) showed that Facebook and Instagram have the double standard
: when judging pictures with bare humans, and many users’ accounts are closed
: due the rule of posting pictures. Moreover, Steinfeld (2017) claimed that the
: reason why Facebook banned the topless pictures is that Facebook thought that
: some audiences may be sensitive to the pictures. It is necessary to consider
: users’ positions. However, Fischtein (2015) mentioned that people aged 60
: and over were least accepting of female topless behavior. It is because older
: people tend to be more conservative. It means that the most main users of
: social media, younger peoples, accept topless women more than older people.
: For another, Steinfeld (2017) claimed that the laws of public indecency are
: nebulous, so people can explain them in their own ways. In conclusion, the
: reason why Facebook banned users is not very reasonable, because just
: minority users can not accept pictures with topless women, but they really
: have a choice to reject them. In addition, to argue this controversial
: phenomenon, artists created the image of “an acceptable nipple”, a male
: nipple for people to paste it on their topless pictures.
先说,我刚刚推文把Wheeling看成第一句,我错了。
而且刚刚推文只是快速看过,表达还是有不好地方。
第一个引用:Wheeling(2015)
说明在social media有双重标准,但没有表达出女性受到较不公平对待,
你要不要找原文有更明确的句子。
第二个引用:Steinfeld(2017)
但是,这个引用无说明出男女受到差异性对待,只是说有些人对这类图片很敏感。
原文可能有更精准的句子,你找看看。
第三个引用:
此说明在60岁以上年长者,对女性裸露接受度是最低,原因是他们比较保守。
但是你过度延伸意思在It means这句话。首先,原引用句无指出在social media
,你加了social media,如果原引用文有,你就要加上引用句,
否则你自己更改作者意思,作者可能只是问卷调查,被你改成social media;
再来,the most main users也是一样。
我觉得这个引用有擦到主旨,只是不知道原文有没有特指social media。
在立场上,
moreover连接第一第二引用,视为同立场。It's necessary...
这句在支持第二个引用,紧接着是however,然后第三个引用。
既然第三有擦到边,前又有however,所以前两个引用,与第三是对立面吗?
即使第一个引用,明确地说明与此段主旨同,还是因为however,变得奇怪。
最后,
引用再更清楚地,与主旨连结。
然后,我觉得如果是一般写作练习,一个段落找一个正方,一个反方就好。
以上只是小弟一点小小个人意见,参考看看。
: Hundreds years ago, people were in a patriarchy. Wheelng (2015) also
: claimed
: that women are more likely to be treated as sex objects. Patriarchy is a
: social system in which men have all the power. The society was controlled by
: men, and women were just properties of men. In addition, some people do not
: care that women are being dominated by men, and some women even promote this
: situations to others, including their daughters. Even in modern times, some
: people still treat women as sex objects. It causes the belief that women’s
: bodies are sexual and should be covered. However, this concept of females is
: really out of date, because in women’s view, men’s bodies are also sexual,
: but topless men can be accepted and not against the law of public indecency.
: To eliminate the bad tradition from patriarchy, the unfair attitudes toward
: women must be changed.
: In short, women really have right to show their breasts in public.
: There are
: many concepts of this topic in three sides, gender equality, social media,
: and patriarchy. Compared to attitudes toward topless men, attitudes toward
: topless women are too biased. Now, advanced countries are working for gender
: equality, but just the view of sex is still conservative. In social media,
: the double standard toward different genders is unreasonable. For another,
: patriarchy has limited a lot of women’s rights for a long time, and it is
: time to change this unreasonable situation. In conclusion, gender topless
: equality is necessary and represents an important process of women’s right.
: If women can show themselves without bias, the relationship between different
: genders would be better, and the society would be kinder and fairer to women.
: 因为要用到APA格式引用的关系 找两方观点相关的文章已经很头大了
: 却更被说"没看到三个side的各两方论点"
: 虽然列给老师看了 但跟他说还是一个头两个大
: 尤其在Social media那一段 老师是说没两方点 但我是要反驳"Facebook方的想法"
: 是因为我说得太委婉吗(同学表示) 还是Organization上的问题呢(不习惯的点)
: 因为老师一直跳针的点是他不清楚哪个点 但跟他问了很久他却也只是说不行
: 所以想请各位提供意见 感谢

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com