[闲聊] Polygon关于Tlous2媒体争议的文章

楼主: carotyao (汐止吴慷仁)   2020-07-01 15:12:06
https://reurl.cc/nz35Nv
节录一部分
前面是在讲严格准则到底有多严格,
评论"准则"不能包含任何关键剧情叙述跟任何特别场面,
也不能任何透漏任何角色命运,这让网站很难有所评论。
https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/wxqnxy/last-of-us-part-2-review
vice在这篇评论中表示有些让人难忘的场面造成了他们对角色以及故事的兴趣减少,
所有人对于复仇的都像是被强迫推进的,叙事风格充满了压抑的凄凉与暴力。
然后就被顽皮狗给海巡到了,
觉得他们的评论不公平而且下了指导棋,
他们说虽然对话过程不是有对抗性的,但这种事情是非常不寻常的。
目前顽皮狗公关对这不表示回应。
心得:ign jp果然真大哥
Discussion about the survival horror game was also hampered by unusually
restrictive embargo guidelines, which included sentences like “DO NOT
include any beat-by-beat descriptions of pivotal narrative or cutscenes
moments” and “DO NOT reveal the fate of ANY character or the inciting event.
” This prevented websites from discussing any specifics of the game’s
story, which was tricky considering that the game reveals something
surprising within its first two hours that impacts the remainder of its 20-
to 30-hour journey. Curiously, at least one website, GameSpot, actually
published two reviews, one without spoilers and one that dove right into
those details. The latter was published after the embargo was fully lifted.
Why go through such lengths, especially when the internet was flooded with
half-informed takes and speculation based on what had already leaked?
Control. Naughty Dog no longer steered the narrative of The Last of Us Part
2, and this was one way to try and regain control. The studio had already
gone to great efforts to maintain a tight grip on what folks knew about the
experience. As Kotaku reported, Naughty Dog at one point showed a fake scene
during a trailer to make people believe that a character would be more
present in the game than they actually were.
The vibe around the game hasn’t gotten much better since then. On June 12,
Vice published its review of The Last of Us Part 2, in which critic Rob Zacny
said that while the game had “memorable moments” that made for great “
spectacle,” he was less taken with the story and characters. “Nobody ever
reconsiders their quest for vengeance,” Zacny wrote. “Everyone acts under a
kind of vindictive compulsion that goes little remarked and unexamined.”
Zacny went on to describe the game’s message as complacent, full of “
oppressive bleakness and violence.”
While the vast majority of reviews have lavished The Last of Us Part 2 with
all sorts of praise, a handful of outlets — Polygon included — have been
slightly more critical of the blockbuster game. According to Zacny, Vice’s
review prompted a Sony representative to reach out on behalf of Naughty Dog.
“They felt some of the conclusions I reached in my review were unfair and
dismissed some meaningful changes or improvements,” Zacny told Polygon over
Twitter messages.
Zacny clarified that the exchange wasn’t “confrontational,” but that it
was nonetheless “unusual,” as the site doesn’t typically have big
publishers asking in an official capacity why a review reads the way it does.
Such things can happen, of course, though often with smaller developers, or
from publishers who have spotted a factual error in a piece that they want
corrected.
“I was happy to unpack a bit of my reasoning, however, and received a
perfectly cordial message in response,” Zacny said. Naughty Dog’s PR team
declined to comment on Polygon’s inquiry about its exchange with Vice.
作者: CrazyLord (Lucian)   2020-07-01 15:13:00
现在看势头不对才想切割停损了吗
作者: louis0724 (louis0724)   2020-07-01 15:14:00
虽然早知道一定有摸头 但终于有媒体敢出来证明了是吧
作者: ray1478953 (龍蛋)   2020-07-01 15:15:00
这家不是本来就是少数说实话的
作者: jensheng09 (甲甲都从后面来)   2020-07-01 15:15:00
不能透漏 = 打最高分 低能逻辑 低能媒体
作者: dnek (哪啊哪啊的合气道)   2020-07-01 15:15:00
sjw式评论,我准你写的才能写
作者: dustlike (灰尘)   2020-07-01 15:15:00
这样看来IGN日本根本不甩顽皮狗给的限制耶以续作而言的剧情问题都写出来了
作者: poke001 (黑色双鱼)   2020-07-01 15:16:00
所以顽皮狗还可以指导评测该怎么写阿XD
作者: lomorobin (翰)   2020-07-01 15:16:00
笨蛋都看得出来有摸头,承不承认而已,索皇的上意就是不准谈剧情,所以媒体的10/10就是指剧情以外的部分。
作者: RoaringWolf (滚狼)   2020-07-01 15:16:00
分数顺便要求只能打10分吧
作者: charmingpink (charmingpink)   2020-07-01 15:16:00
我看过没问题才能评分
作者: loveangel718 (紅蓮愛天使教教主)   2020-07-01 15:17:00
这家不是气到没打分吗? 还是我记错家
作者: poke001 (黑色双鱼)   2020-07-01 15:17:00
这样连给的分数都能指导我看也不意外
作者: FinallyFind (找不到)   2020-07-01 15:18:00
问题是敢跳出来讲的有几家?
作者: a71085 (iii)   2020-07-01 15:19:00
注意看一下 是索尼爸爸代表顽皮狗出来抗议
作者: john0909 (酱洞玖洞玖)   2020-07-01 15:20:00
IGN JP 真的有胆量
作者: jorden0804 (无极呆呆)   2020-07-01 15:20:00
这是中共吧 直接审查你的评论 可怜阿 SONY
作者: vsepr55 (vsepr55)   2020-07-01 15:21:00
有时间拿来改媒体的作文怎么不好好精进自己呢==

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com