Re: [请益] 关于蜘蛛人二女主角(有雷慎入)

楼主: jefferycc (dark-moon)   2014-04-27 11:00:29
※ 引述《NomoreSeven (Alger)》之铭言:
: 防雷页
: 后面女主角掉下去 蜘蛛人喷她 阿 不是 是蜘蛛人喷丝救她的时后 我朋友说她有撞到头 才死的
: 可是我完全没看到有撞到头?!还是他看到的头跟我不同个?我一直以为是脊椎断掉死的
: 所以女主角到底是怎么死的?!
: 难道是被我帅死的?(误)
资料出处 维基百科
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gwen_Stacy
[这边讲的是漫画版]
Death[edit]
Main article: The Night Gwen Stacy Died
In The Amazing Spider-Man #121 (June 1973), by writer Gerry Conway and
penciller Gil Kane, inked by John Romita Sr and Tony Mortellaro, the Green
Goblin (Norman Osborn, who has identified Peter Parker as Spider-Man) holds
Gwen Stacy captive on a tower of the George Washington Bridge. Spider-Man
arrives to fight the Green Goblin. When the Goblin throws Gwen Stacy off the
bridge, Spider-Man catches her by her leg with a string of web. He initially
thinks he has saved her. After he pulls her back onto the bridge, he realizes
she has already died. In shock and anger, Spider-Man nearly kills the Green
Goblin in retaliation, but in the end chooses not to do so. But despite his
restraint, the Green Goblin seemingly dies anyway when he is impaled by his
own goblin glider while attempting to kill Spider-Man. Norman Osborn would
not return for nearly three hundred issues. Peter is left wondering if Gwen
was dead before the fall or if his attempt to save her by breaking her fall
snapped her neck.
The death of Gwen Stacy had an enormous impact in the world of comic-book
fandom.[11] Before her, except possibly as part of an origin story,
superheroes did not fail so catastrophically; nor did a loved one of the
superhero die so suddenly without warning.[12][13][14] Because of this, some
fans and historians take the death of Gwen Stacy as one marker of the end of
the period they refer to as the Silver Age of Comic Books.[citation needed]
In the real world, physicist James Kakalios shows in his book The Physics of
Superheroes that, consistent with Newton's laws of motion, the sudden stop
would have killed Gwen Stacy.[15] The comic book Civil War: Casualties of
War: Captain America/Iron Man (2007) concurred that the proximate cause of
death was the sudden stop during a high-speed fall. An issue of Peter
Parker/Spider-Man revisits the issue, and further confirms Gwen died of a
broken neck due to the use of the webbing.[volume & issue needed]
Contradictorily, in the fourth issue of Marvels, the police forensic
scientist reports that she died from the shock of the fall prior her neck
breaking, placing the blame on the Green Goblin and not Spider-Man.
大致是说 "关" 他是被 绿恶魔 (诺曼奥斯朋,而非电影里的哈利奥斯朋)被俘虏在华盛顿
桥上,蜘蛛人理所当然来应战。
后来 "关" 被绿恶魔丢下桥,蜘蛛人用蜘蛛丝捉住"关"的脚,蜘蛛人以为救到了,但是
把"关"拉上来以后发现她已经死了。
"关"的死让蜘蛛人愤怒至极,差点把绿恶魔杀了,但是蜘蛛人最后还是选择了不杀他,
但是尽管蜘蛛人克制了自己的杀意,绿恶魔最后还是因为试图用恶魔飞行器杀死蜘蛛人
而死 (这部分感觉比较像旧的蜘蛛人1 ) 。 蜘蛛人则被"关"的死因而困惑:"关"是再坠落前就死了,
还是因为自己想救她导致脖子断裂而死。
"关"的死亡则让影迷认为是"白银时代(silver age)"的结束,(这部分回文里有,不多说)
现实生活中的物理学家 James Kakalios 在他的著作 "超级英雄的物理学" 中表示,
依据牛顿的惯性定理,突然的停止是会导致"关"的死亡。
但是在MARVEL后来发布的漫画里,警界法医报告中认定,"关"在脖子断掉以前,已经因为
急坠所导致惊恐而死,说明了"关"的直接死因是绿恶魔所致,非因蜘蛛人。
上面粗浅的翻译供大家参考。
作者: DDD (3D爱情动作片)   2014-04-27 11:17:00
绿恶魔儿子什么时候出来?
作者: mysmalllamb (小羊)   2014-04-27 12:56:00
无论如何,怎么可能把死因归给蜘蛛人呢?顶多只有救援有效或无效的问题,因为那个“突然停止”就算没有蜘蛛人出手一样会发生。
作者: cn0341 (BigH)   2014-04-27 13:20:00
后来漫画特地解释关是先死 主要是让蜘蛛人解套
作者: mysmalllamb (小羊)   2014-04-27 14:37:00
如果真的曾经有这个套,那真是很无聊又没逻辑的套

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com