Re: Philosophy is a bunch of empty ideas

楼主: AlfredEgo (Follow the Sun)   2015-01-23 10:50:29
※ 引述《AlfredEgo (Follow the Sun)》之铭言:
: http://tinyurl.com/nb6d3py
: 有人造反啦!
: 或是这是战争的第一鎗?
https://www.academia.edu/10272503/Review_of_Peter_Unger_s_Empty_Ideas
"Unger's usual procedure is just to report an analytic philosopher's view and
then confidently assert without argument that it is concretely empty, often
adding with slightly less confidence and still no argument that it is
analytically empty. If he had really uncovered some dark secret about what
analytic philosophers are up to, one might have expected the case for the
prosecution to take a somewhat more elaborate form." (Timothy Williamson)
作者: yyla (會家子)   2015-01-27 01:25:00
Unger这本书的内容并没有书名那么强大 Williamson的评论算挺中肯的

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com