[讨论] 乔帅搞特权?

楼主: yftsai (aa)   2022-01-08 02:45:16
关于对球王的批评
说他高调,搞特权,走后门
很多是来自于他ig那句"exemption permission"
我去翻了澳洲移民署的规定
我觉得可能误会大了
https://covid19.homeaffairs.gov.au/travel-restrictions
仅列以下几点讨论,详细可看连结
1. Fully vaccinated Australian citizens, permanent residents and eligible visa
holders can travel to and from Australia without needing to apply for a
travel exemption.
完整接踵疫苗者不需申请豁免
2. All other temporary visa holders seeking to travel to Australia must apply
for a travel exemption.
其他持有短期签证者或没打疫苗者必须申请旅行豁免
3. Travel to Australia is only available if you are exempt or you have been
granted an individual exemption.
拥有豁免资格或得到个人豁免才能进入澳洲
注:由以上三点可知,exemption并非特权或开后门,
而是明明白白写在规定里的
有打疫苗的可以自动取得exemption
没打疫苗也不是不能进,而是需要有特殊理由,符合特殊规定(详后述)
并得到豁免许可
4. You are automatically exempt from the travel restrictions and can enter
Australia (without obtaining an individual exemption) if you are:
豁免资格:澳洲公民、永久居民、已施打完整疫苗的签证持有者.....(不赘述)
注:澳洲公民不论有没有施打疫苗皆有豁免资格
5. If you hold an eligible visa and are not fully vaccinated you must apply for
and be granted an individual travel exemption.
未施打疫苗外国人的必须拿到个人豁免(individual travel exemption)
6. Individual exemptions
You may be considered for an individual travel exemption by the Commissioner
of the Australian Border Force or decision makers if you are:
个人豁免须符合以下条件:(仅列出乔帅可能适用的条件)
a foreign national whose entry into Australia would be in the national
interest, supported by the Australian Government or a state or territory
government authority
由联邦政府、州政府或边境管理局认定,外国人进入有利国家利益
注:没有医疗豁免(medical exemption)
7. You must hold a visa and an exemption to Australia’s travel restrictions
before you travel.
旅行至澳洲前你必须持有签证和边境管制的豁免(网络申请)
8. If you are not granted an exemption, you should not continue with travel
plans, as you will not be permitted to board a flight to Australia. If you
are granted a travel exemption, you will need to take evidence of that
exemption decision to the airport.
若你没有拿到豁免,你无法登机。如果你有拿到豁免,请在机场出示证明。
乔帅因为没打疫苗,所以申请exemption
他登机前肯定已经拿到exemption了,澳洲政府也肯定审过了
但是不知为何在机场被取消签证?
另一个问题,他是以哪个条件拿到exemption?
回到第六点个人豁免条件
并没有看到有医疗豁免
我看规定可能符合的只有一项
就是联邦或州政府基于国家利益给你边境管制的豁免
那跟乔帅准备的文件有什么关系?
结论
那篇IG的exemption permission跟高调、特权、走后门完全无关
而是任何人未施打疫苗者都可以,也必须申请才能进入澳洲
乔帅有没有拿到不适合接种疫苗的证明或有没有六个月内染疫并不重要
因为那并非构成豁免的条件
而事实上乔帅能不能进去其实只要州政府或联邦政府点头就能进
看起来其实是个政治问题?
*补充clifflee版友的指正
https://reurl.cc/e697WM
a. Fully vaccinated Australian citizens, permanent residents and from 15
December 2021, eligible visa holders can travel to and from Australia without
needing to apply for a travel exemption.
已接踵疫苗者不需要申请旅行豁免
b. Travellers with acceptable proof they cannot be vaccinated for medical
reasons, and children under 12 can access the same travel arrangement as
fully vaccinated travellers.
持有无法接种疫苗证明者可以和以接踵疫苗者相同的管道出入境
c. If you cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons, you will need to provide
proof that you cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons to airline staff. You
should also check any requirements, particularly quarantine requirements, in
the state or territory to which you are travelling. Proof that you cannot be
vaccinated for medical reasons is separate to a Commissioner’s travel
exemption.
若因医疗原因无法接踵,您需要提供证明给航空公司。请注意各州其他要求,包含隔离。
此证明不同于旅行豁免。
结论
若是医疗豁免,需准备医疗证明,需载明无法接种疫苗的原因
但是医疗豁免不需事先申请,不须事先审查
只需要在出发时准备好证明即可
若以IG乔的说法
应该是在出发前就已经申请好豁免了
看起来动用此管道入境的机率低
作者: coolfish1103 (Fish)   2022-01-08 04:16:00
你就在帮他洗啊,还被指正,等周一戏码不就好了?
作者: purification (我爱你 我爱你)   2022-01-08 09:44:00
我觉得就是澳网和州政府需要他来打所以帮忙弄
作者: Taiwanbunbun (台湾好棒棒)   2022-01-08 10:13:00
真相出来前大喇喇地说人家走后门 倒是讲得很自然
作者: LucasGiolito ( ♥唯 ♥孝周 ♥)   2022-01-08 10:19:00
洗地中 洗刷刷
作者: coolfish1103 (Fish)   2022-01-08 12:48:00
怎么还在辩啊,原PO是没出过国不知道有些国家入境时可以拿你的手机看你的社交软件吗?看完觉得不行他也是当场撤销你的签证好吗?然后不要说没签证没同意就不会飞了,看看去年谢淑薇怎么从法国飞墨西哥打年终的,她当下也没有合格的签证好吗?最后还不是靠担保才能打比赛?只是澳洲政府跟州政府没要帮你的偶像担保而已!还有,签证没有给了就一定能进的。给了也可以随时取消,进去本来就要照主人的规矩。主人不高兴也可以随时请你离开,捷克女就是个例子。
作者: Taiwanbunbun (台湾好棒棒)   2022-01-08 13:55:00
回刀男 很多人否认澳洲&澳网方的问题吧 想把责任全部丢在囧身上
作者: FantasyChopi (Fantasy_Chopin)   2022-01-08 14:35:00
囧黑不会跟你讲那么多道理啦
作者: darkestnight (GG)   2022-01-09 18:24:00
原po我是真心建议你的阅读能力跟逻辑最好找个时间去加强一下 整篇推文对争议点已经解释的够清楚了你的反击却连一丁点都没打在质疑者的点上

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com