[新闻] 不是标题:男选手被罚比女选手多

楼主: shermanmt (sherman)   2018-09-18 02:22:30
https://nypost.com/2018/09/17/serena-williams-husband-loses-it-over-times-tennis-research/
节录一下:
A statistical analysis of crime and punishment of male and female players at
grand slam tournaments, published in the Times over the weekend, showed male
players are punished much more frequently than their WTA Tour counterparts.
本周末,纽约时报统计了男性与女性选手在大满贯期间所受的犯规和警告,统计显示男性
选手所接受的判罚比女性选手多出不少。
The figures published by The Times show since 1998 male players were fined for
code of conduct breaches 1,517 times compared to the 535 times female players
were penalized.
纽约时报统计从1998年开始,男子选手接受到1,517次违规警告,而女子选手则接受了
535次。
The article did not make any conclusions surrounding Williams’ claim that she
was penalized for verbal abuse only because she is a woman.
该报导并没有对于“小威廉斯声称因其为女性而被判任意骂人”一事做出任何结论。
The article’s biggest find was that women at grand slams have been fined for
coaching 152 times, almost double the 87 fines handed out to male players for
the same offense. The figures obtained show that men received 649 fines for
breaking rackets to 99 for women in tens of thousands of matches in the four
Grand Slams over the last two decades.
该文章最大的发现在于,女子选手在大满贯被判152次违规接受指导,几乎是男子选手87
次违规的两倍。这个统计也显示,男子选手因为摔拍而受到649次警告,而女子选手则受
到99次警告。数据来自于过去20年的四大满贯赛。
Men were fined 344 times compared to 140 for “audible obscenity” and 287 to
67 for unsportsmanlike conduct.
男子选手因为“可以听见的不雅语言”被罚344次,相对于女子选手的140次。
男子选手被警告287次缺乏运动精神的行为,女子选手则67次。
***
平衡报导一下。小威的老公发火的原因,是因为他认为记者的数据搞错重点。小威的意思
是“同样的行为女子选手比男子选手受到更多的警告”,而纽时的报导是只统计“被罚”
而没有统计“被罚/有违规行为”的比例。
他举例说如果男子选手有不雅言行3440次,但只被抓到340次,那就是10%被抓。同时间,
如果女子选手有不雅言行700次,但被抓到140次,那就是20%被抓。这代表女子选手被抓
违规的比例是男子选手的两倍。
他还捐了$7,140给一个基金会,“期待让下一代可以学习基本的统计学” XDDD
我是觉得他的论述可能有逻辑,但是没有数据背书的话,比较像是空谈。
作者: coolfish1103 (Fish)   2018-09-18 10:25:00
就是因为不可能去计算这个东西所以才拿出来讲咩...且罚男生到底跟罚女生有啥关系,小威是跟男生打吗?
作者: sttarmbcb390 (L.H.)   2018-09-18 12:13:00
男选手骂主审几句就判输了啦 男选手更严吧
作者: pandaforever (一生放荡不羁爱圆仔)   2018-09-19 02:46:00
WTA都出来支持小威了。小威她老公可以赞助一下WTA做研究。看能不能不要感觉,拿出证据

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com