楼主:
searenata (HauSiaulism)
2017-08-18 02:12:02※ 引述《fffffff4 (使用者在线上)》之铭言：
: 来源：
: The daily caller
: 标题：
: Feminist Says Dunkirk Is A Bad Movie Because It Screams‘Men-Only’
我想提醒一下英文报导并没有把“缺女角”这件事放到标题
只强调该女权人士（简称该女）认为这部电影是拍给男人看的（Men-Only）
: 女权人士: 敦克尔克缺乏女角 沦父权论述
所以这句话完全是超译。放到标题就是标准的“标题杀人法”。
我是觉得啦，要战女权也不必这样。
该女原文连结
http://www.marieclaire.com/celebrity/news/a28515/dunkirk-movie-review/
基本上就是一篇废文。
我英文没多好对照google翻译看完的，看完觉得根本浪费我时间。
文章中并没有提出什么明确理由去说明，
这部片为何让她觉得 "men-only" ，
倒是花了不少篇幅在讽刺这部电影很普通，
唯一特别的地方是起用Harry Styles（当然是一个讽刺的说法）。
可能她认为，指出“敦克尔克是一部不特别的战争电影”，
就已经足以说明这部片是"men-only"。
靠北，没看电影也要看影评啊，这么弱是要怎么说服人。
所以整篇文章几乎都是酸言酸语，唯一具体的内容是靠北诺兰说：
你想拍个特别的、颠覆战争片典型的东西，干嘛不拍二战时期的女性。
以女权人士来讲，这种主张只不过是不意外的正常能量释放，
英文报导的标题虽然中规中矩，
但坦白讲挑这种话提出来吵根本就是骗点击率的，
这种废文不要理他就好了啊。
干，我也不知道要讲什么惹。
看完这些东西我觉得我在浪费生命，
只好来板上发这篇干话赚点P币。
: 内文：
: Christopher Nolan’s “Dunkirk” is being celebrated as one of the strongest m
: ovies of the year—and may perhaps rank among one of the best war movies ever
: made alongside “Saving Private Ryan,” “Hacksaw Ridge,” and “Black Hawk Do
: wn.” Like the other great films, it doesn’t glorify war, but instead emphasi
: zes the tragedy of war. But because male critics are praising it, women’s mag
: azine Marie Claire has seen fit to trash the film for “celebrating maleness”
: —asking instead why war movies aren’t being made for women.
: 敦克尔克被誉为最伟大的战争电影，与抢救雷恩大兵等电影齐名。但女性杂志Marie Clai
: re却批评本电影“高抬男性气质”，并质疑战争片为什么无法让女性感动。
: Writing for Marie Claire, Mehera Bonner declared “Dunkirk” to be “basic.”
: “And look, it’s not like I need every movie to have ‘strong female leads.’
: Wonder Woman can probably tide me over for at least a year and I understand t
: hat this was dominated by brave male soldiers. I get that,” she wrote, before
: slamming the film for its “general vibe.”
: Despite enjoying the film’s intense moments and even the performances of its
: actors, including One Direction’s Harry Styles in his first big screen appear
: ance, the Marie Claire writer slams Dunkirk for being “designed for men to ma
: n-out over.”
: 杂志专栏作家Mehera Bonner表示，敦克尔克很平庸的一部片。她说：“我不是要每部电
: 影都有女强人当主角，我很喜欢神力女超人，但我也了解战争是男人打的。”
: 但她也批评敦克尔克是为男人而拍的电影。
: “The tenor of the people applauding it just screams ‘men-only’,” she conti
: nued, citing that the only reason male critics liked it was because it allowed
: them to feel manly.
: 她表示，只有男人才能欣赏此片，男人之所以喜欢，是因为看完会觉得有男子气概。
: Bonner continues: “To me, Dunkirk felt like an excuse for men to celebrate ma
: leness—which apparently they don’t get to do enough. Fine, great, go forth,
: but if Nolan’s entire purpose is breaking the established war movie mold and
: doing something different—why not make a movie about women in World War II?”
: The Marie Claire writer argues that it’s the responsibility of top-tier dire
: ctors like Nolan to make the films she wants more of.
: 敦克尔克成了男人高抬男子气概的借口。
: 如果诺兰导演想要打破战争片传统，何不拍部二战中的女性？
: This year’s “Wonder Woman” and “Atomic Blonde” are both highly rated film
: s, revealing little gender bias among film critics. Likewise, the female-drive
: n “Mad Max: Fury Road” was equally enjoyed by critics of either sex, earning
: it a spot as one of the highest rated films ever made. Films about women in t
: imes of war have been made, several to critical acclaim—including “Zero Dark
: Thirty” and “The English Patient.” According to film reviewers, each of th
: ese films broke the mold by taking typically male settings and centering them
: around female protagonists.
: Dunkirk was a prominent event in military history, but is rarely given notice
: in pop culture. To anyone who’s heard of Dunkirk, the evacuation is largely r
: emembered as both a miracle and a disaster for the Allied forces in Europe dur
: ing World War II. Failing to defend France against the Germans, the British we
: re forced to evacuate over 338,000 troops with the aid of private civilians.
: However, over 30,000 troops were left behind to be captured as prisoners of wa
: r to the German army. The British press managed to turn the loss into a sort o
: f victory with the “Dunkirk Spirit” that showed the solidarity of the Britis
: h people in saving the lives of their countrymen. With “Dunkirk,” Christophe
: r Nolan shed light on an event that would’ve otherwise relegated to the histo
: ry books.
: https://tinyurl.com/ybutwwoh