Re: [新闻] NASA 公布 “EM DRIVE”实验成功

楼主: Antler5566 (鹿茸五六)   2015-11-09 14:08:36
鲁科学家导读:
※ 引述《okura (大仓)》之铭言:
: 1.媒体来源:
: 英国dailymail
: 2.完整新闻标题:
: Is deep space travel a step closer to reality? Nasa reveals successful test
: of 'impossible' fuel-free engine that breaks the laws of physics
: 3.完整新闻内文:
: 摘要:
: EM Drive Fuel-free engine could take a spacecraft to Mars in 10 weeks.
: Creates thrust by bouncing microwaves in chamber, using solar power.
: Nasa has conducted more tests using an improved experimental process.
: Test designed to remove errors from earlier study but still produced thrust.
: Scientists still aren't sure how this happens as it defies the laws of physics.
: 全文:
: An 'impossible' fuel-free engine, which could take a humans to Mars in just
: 10 weeks, is still defying science after another batch of tests by Nasa
: suggested the thruster does work.
: The so-called EM Drive creates thrust by bouncing microwaves around in an
: enclosed chamber, and uses only solar power.
: When the concept was first proposed, it was considered implausible because it
: went against the laws of physics - and subsequent tests of the engine have
: shown that the idea could revolutionise space travel.
: March posted on the Nasa Spaceflight forum in reply to an unpublished paper
: that claims the unaccounted thrust is generated by something known as the
: Lorentz force.
EM Drive原理宣称是利用劳伦兹力产生产生冲力
: The Lorentz force is the force that is exerted by a magnetic field on a
: moving electric charge.
劳伦兹力是磁场作用在移动电荷上的磁力
各位修过普通物理, 应该知道移动电荷在磁场受力
_ _ _ _ _
F=q (v x B) = q [(ds/dt) xB ]
但是要让太空船加速, 此磁力必须作功来产生动能
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
W= F.s = q (v x B). s = q [(ds/dt) xB ]. s = 0
而磁力跟位移的外积, 再跟位移取内积必为零
所以磁力必不做功!!
这则新闻里提到动力来源是罗伦兹力, 肯定是错的
看到这边, 已经可以知道这则新闻必定是唬烂
作者: StevenAn (Steven An)   2015-11-09 14:10:00
推一个
作者: limitex (界王)   2015-11-09 14:10:00
忘光了啦干
作者: yyff   2015-11-09 14:10:00
我承认我有看没有懂 囧
作者: iecju520 (哎依喜德鲁)   2015-11-09 14:11:00
我一开始也觉得是假的
作者: h4k (4kkkk)   2015-11-09 14:12:00
快推以免人家说我们看不懂
作者: tenninetall (爱只需要张开)   2015-11-09 14:13:00
原来如此 师爷你给翻译翻译
作者: douglasjs (帅到吐)   2015-11-09 14:13:00
不是有冲力,有就该研究看看
作者: signm (sin)   2015-11-09 14:14:00
可是新闻不是说已经做出来了?
作者: bernon (沒什麼)   2015-11-09 14:14:00
早就说是假的了,原PO英雄所见略同 (喂
作者: Murasaki0110 (麦当劳欢乐送)   2015-11-09 14:14:00
说中文
作者: tsubasawolfy (悠久の翼)   2015-11-09 14:14:00
因为可以不用燃料挂个太阳能板就能持续作功吧
作者: L0v35 (是零不是歐)   2015-11-09 14:15:00
DailyMail就是假外媒阿 水准跟台媒差不多
作者: tsubasawolfy (悠久の翼)   2015-11-09 14:15:00
比起现在用"漂"的好上一点点
作者: L0v35 (是零不是歐)   2015-11-09 14:16:00
更别说这新闻讲的是半年前的东西
作者: jackals60 (Sixty Jackals)   2015-11-09 14:17:00
没错,我的paper上也有提到这观点
作者: cdcardabc (觉得难笑就给个推)   2015-11-09 14:17:00
签名档是沙小XDDD
作者: lolucky531 (伦伦)   2015-11-09 14:18:00
嗯 跟我想的差不多
作者: DIIIV (DiV)   2015-11-09 14:19:00
电磁学呀 略懂略懂

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com