Re: [爆卦] 台独没有军队根本不会成功

楼主: Luke2000 (香蕉共和国)   2014-07-04 18:30:40
这篇英文是1950年美国驻台代办对国务院的工作报告,
连结在此。http://ppt.cc/ig5o
文中的Peter Huang可能系指刺蒋案的黄文雄,
至于Philip Ng是谁,我就懒得去追索了。
投降派对独派冷嘲热讽久矣,
我等不及想看到投降派看到台湾独立成功时如丧考妣的嘴脸。
各位也不妨回到1950年那个时空去思考,彼时的台独为什么需要队才能成事?
答案很明显,
因为当时的台独面对的是蒋介石溃败之后从中国溃逃来台的大量武装军队。
而当时的台湾人处于手无寸铁的极度难堪处境中。
※ 引述《shawntanco (雄探可)》之铭言:
: 作者 ThomasJP (笔剑春秋梁父吟) 看板 armedFanClub
: 标题 超译师枢安
: 时间 Mon Jun 30 19:36:56 2014
: ───────────────────────────────────────
: As new arrival Taipei I am being given the "treatment" by Formosan Independence
: "Movement". Conversations with Peter Huang and Philip Ng and perusal of their
: propaganda have served only to establish their utter lack of realism, absence
: of any militant and armed popular foundation, and complete reliance on US to
: achieve their aims and assure their livelihood forever.
: 这次一到台北,我就跟那帮自以为是在搞台独的家伙见了一面。
: 我跟黄彼得还有菲力NG交换了看法,草泥马的这根本就一帮没脑的鲁蛇。
: 说要搞独立,结果不只没军队,连民兵也没半个。只想靠美国人帮他们打天下,以后还要
: 美国帮他们保家卫国。
: It seemed desirable to attempt to straighten out their thinking in relation to
: China scene as to US, and to prevent misconception as to nature of any personal
: relations with me. In brief, they were told in friendly manner, as my personal
: opinion, that Formosans themselves, unarmed, could not get rid of Chinese now
: on Island
: 看来矫正他们对中国前景的理解,对美国是有些好处的。而且我也不想让他们对跟我的交
: 情产生什么误解。
: 我很客气地简单告诉他们,只靠嘴砲是不可能把岛上的689赶走的。
: US would require several divisions of troops plus supporting naval and air
: forces to take and keep control over Island, a responsibility which we are not
: prepared to assume
: 美国必须派出几个师的大兵,加上海军和空军的支援才能占领并且保住这个小岛。
: 但是我们不打算自己跳进这个坑里。
: for time being any hope for independence lay with Nationalists not with
: Communists, and thus measures designed weaken Nationalists merely served
: increase chances Communist control,
: 要知道,干掉中华民国的结果,就是让中华人民共和国更容易解放台湾。
: so Formosans must recognize facts, not avoid them, and they should not forget
: that Formosa fits into large pattern from which it cannot be separated
: arbitrarily, and although US sympathetic to Formosan aspirations, there were
: very few grounds for optimism now and foreseeable future.
: 所以大头病们别再逃避现实了,台湾是不可能从中国大陆旁边搬到太平洋中间的。
: 即使美国觉得你们很可怜,但套句阿扁的话“现在做不到,以后也做不到”。
作者: tofu0208   2014-07-04 18:35:00
查证 推
作者: ispy03532003 (臭酸肥它)   2014-07-04 19:10:00
作者: chenweichih (走路常跌倒)   2014-07-04 19:11:00
还没发现吗? 当时跟现在一样 对手还是更强的中共
作者: monismile (古今多少事)   2014-07-04 19:15:00
哪有一样? 当时的美国建交的中国是中华民国 ok?
作者: chenweichih (走路常跌倒)   2014-07-04 19:16:00
我的意思是 当时也是要军队 现在也一样
作者: edison (edison)   2014-07-04 19:27:00
现在当然不一样,当时需要军队,现在需要的是一整排的钢铁人

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com