[问题] GRE OV阅读一题 (P.22)

楼主: thousandfish (我也还不确定 但是我妈之)   2014-09-06 03:27:11
While the best sixteenth-century Renaissance scholars mastered the classics of
ancient Roman literature in the original Latin and understood them in their
original historical context, most of the scholar's educated contemporaries
knew the classics only from school lessons on selected Latin texts. These were
chosen by Renaissance teachers after much deliberation, for works written by
and for the sophisticated adults of pagan Rome were not always considered
suitable for the Renaissance young: the central Roman classics refused (as
classics often do) to teach appropriate morality and frequently suggested
the opposite. Teachers accordingly made students' needs, not textual and
historical accuracy, their supreme interest, chopping dangerous texts into
short phrases, and using these to impart lessons extemporaneously on a variety
of subjects, from syntax to science. Thus I believe that a modern reader cannot
know the associations that a line of ancient Roman poetry or prose had for
any particular educated sixteenth-century reader.
=> 我的理解: 16世纪文艺复兴的学者自己受教育时, 他们研究的罗马经典文学未经筛选,
原汁原味.但是当他们把经典教给学生时,删除了跟异教徒有关不恰当的部分,因此现在学生
学习到的只是片段的知识,散乱在各学科间.主旨是"文艺复兴学者"与"现在学生"两者学习
的不同
1. The passage is primarily concerned with discussing the
A.unsuitability of the Roman classics for the teaching of morality
B.approach that sixteenth-century scholars took to learning the Roman
classics
C.effect that the Roman classics had on educated people in the Renaissance
D.way in which the Roman classics were taught in the sixteenth-century
E.contrast between the teaching of the Roman classics in the Renaissance
and the teaching of the Roman classics today
=> 答案是D 可是我认为E也正确 甚至比D更适合 因为有讲到两者的比较?另外D正确的话
D与B的差别为何? 我也看不太出来@@
很好奇我是哪里理解错误,请各位版友多多指教,谢谢!!
作者: kaifrankwind (大师兄)   2014-09-06 17:20:00
"most of the scholar's educated contemporaries"所以是比较顶尖学者和同时代的一般人(也是16世记)不是和现代学生比 *纪
楼主: thousandfish (我也还不确定 但是我妈之)   2014-09-06 23:35:00
谢谢!! 我本来也有往这方面想 只是最后一句又提到"modern readear"所以还是有些困惑?不好意思我看懂了 自己解答 最后一句是说现在的读者无法理解16世纪的读者如何理解罗马的的文句 因为16世纪的读者归点已被扭曲所以是从前文再延伸出来的结论

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com