FYI, 这是去年我对 fainl project 的 grading criteria:
Peer Review Do review Format Report Insight Contrib Implem Difficulty
10 pts 5 pts 5 pts 10 pts 25pts 20pts 25pts +-10
1. "Do Review": If you provide useful comments: 4.5 ~ 5;
Too few comments: 3.5 ~ 4;
Missing some: < 3
2. Format: Points deduced if not IEEE compliant (e.g. alignment, fonts, etc)
3. Report: English correctness; Information sufficiency.
4. Insight: Depth of your discussion on the project problems.
5. Contribution: How impressive your result is.
6. Implementation: Difficulty, completeness, and coding style of your program.