Re: [文法] 台南一中脑残的英文教师

楼主: ostracize (bucolic)   2026-07-08 11:34:44
As scheduled, they met on February 16.
这里的as scheduled, 可以写成as had been scheduled。
有位台南一中英文教师却写成as it was scheduled。
这种误人子弟的劣师应该加以汰除。
https://pse.is/9aqyzu
他说:【我还原这样是对的,您去问问很厉害的英文高手或英文系教授.
a.Give it to me when it is finished.
可减化成Give it to me when finished.
b.I don't have a new dress made unless it is really needed.
可减化成I don't have a new dress made unless really needed.
c.Because he had been educated abroad,he was versed in all the arts
and sciences of the West.
可减化成Having been educated abroad,he was versed in all the arts
and sciences of the West.
“Having been”可以省略掉
成为educated abroad,he was versed in all the arts
and sciences of the West.
d.Because it had been trained to search for survivors,the dog did
a good job.
可减化成Having been trained to search for survivors,the dog did
a good job.
“Having been”可以省略掉
成为trained to search for survivors,the dog did
a good job.
您看a句,b句,c句,d句就可以知道
还原成原来的句子是“as it was scheduled....”
而不是“as had been scheduled....”
因为it是指那件事,动作没有先后.....
As scheduled,they met on February 16.
是要还原成As it was scheduled,they met on February 16.
还是要还原成As had been scheduled,they met on February 16.
你去问台大英文系教授就知道,老是给我硬ㄠ
一个附属子句里尽然没有主词,我还第一次看过...
AS had been scheduled,they met on February 16.
也无法减化成As scheduled,they met on February 16.
差一点就被你误导....
我说你这句文法错,我就要讲清楚.
AS had been scheduled,they met on February 16.
1.从属子句本身含有主词与动词,是句子的一部分。(取自图解英文法)
2.
http://www1.chihlee.edu.tw/teachers/jeantai/dependent_clause.htm
多字修饰语 - 附属子句(Dependent Clauses)
 
附属子句不能单独存在。它们必须与独立子句结合,成为一个可以单独存在的句子的一部
份。与独立子句不同的是,附属子句系被用来在句子中担任不同的功能。它们可以当名词
用或当修饰语用。根据它们在句子中的功能,我们可以分类出三种基本的附属子句。请记
住:一个附属子句一定包含一个主词和一个动词,但它不能单独存在。
3.
http://www.taiwantestcentral.com/grammar/Title.aspx?ID=257
从属子句 (Subordinate Clauses)
从属子句是以从属连接词或关系代名词起头,它如同一般子句,既有主词又有动词的字群
。从属子句无法表达完整的思维,它不能单独存在。从属子句又称为附属子句 — 意谓著
它必须依附在其他独立子句,才能表达完整的思维。
从属子句依其在句子里所扮演的功能,基本上又可归纳为名词子句、关系子句 、和副词
子句。
由1、2、3知,一个附属子句一定包含一个主词和一个动词。
你懒得翻文法书,至少在网络上google一下,你尽然会写出这样错误的句子
“AS had been scheduled,they met on February 16.”
还说你是台大外文系毕业,笑破人家的大牙.... 】
这个蠢蛋始终坚持as scheduled就是as it was scheduled,it是绝对必要的。
即使我把外籍老师的说明传给它,它还是执迷不悟。
它的习惯是逗点后面不留space,竟然写成尽然。
台南一中怎么会有这种劣师?大概是送钱内定的吧。
作者: kerwinhui (kezza)   2025-07-07 17:10:00
估计是被传染了word diarrhea,以为越多字数越好…

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com