Re: [闲聊] 郭天信v.s林哲瑄

楼主: ELF004 (艾尔夫澪澪肆)   2025-08-25 10:53:58
撇开其他问题不谈
林哲瑄的机体在守备是最顶的
顶到同时期连MLB的正CF可能不超过20个比他好
我可以保证当时NYY的Granderson判断还没虾好
比较接近的应该是Gardner但虾的Arm比他好两个等级
对,MLB一样一堆CF是靠打击在守,正CF守备就是这么难
举例来说最明显的例子,一朗在MLB的CF守备能力是略低于平均水准
所以光论守备,虾机体天赋能力的评价不下一朗
郭天信判断虽然不算差,但光中职目前岳政跟宋88可能就比他略好一点了
林政华跟申浩玮应该也跟他差不多同水准
只能说虾的超烂挥棒跟守中线快速退化的糗样给人印象跟他全盛时期一样深刻
不然光守备中职目前还没人能摸到全盛时期他的地板
Che-Hsuan Lin
Scouting Report: Medium build, without much more room to fill out. Solid
athlete. Compact, level swing through the hitting zone. Not much leverage or
upward plane in swing. Generates fringe-average batspeed. Above-average
approach and pitch recognition. Excels at working counts. Rarely chases
offerings outside of his strike zone. Shows bat control to spoil tough
pitches, hang deep into counts, and get bat on the ball. Struggles to square
up pitches. Can struggle with balance at plate. Swing requires maintenance.
Creates infrequent instances of backspin, with a lot of
contact resulting in weak grounders or flares. Below-average hit tool. Does
not barrel enough balls up to produce average batting averages at the major
league level. Well below-average power projection. Plus speed. Ability to
steal 20 bases in the big leagues. Well-above average defender. Possesses
outstanding defensive instincts. Seems to get a head start on balls off the
bat. Covers excellent ground from
gap-to-gap. Plus-plus arm, with improving accuracy. Projects as a bench
player at the major league level, with emphasis on role as defensive
replacement/pinch runner.
预估MLB 20盗的速度 + 杰出的防守判断 + 最顶的手臂 整体水准高于MLB平均
但打击只有选球高于平均 + contact OK但仰角低 整体水准低于MLB平均
真要说最像的其实是宋88 不过88当初被担忧的打击看起来应该优于中职平均没问题
可喜可贺
作者: beoneg (预感)   2025-08-25 11:12:00
老话一句,重要的还是打击,有打击就会找位置给你

Links booklink

Contact Us: admin [ a t ] ucptt.com