※ 引述《YenChinBiao (阿标)》之铭言：
: 说到天份，就是曹与郭泓志最被人家在讲天份。
: 王建民则是被定位成苦练型，
: 可是天份的真正条件是什么？
: 都在讲因为曹郭球速有多快多快，
: 这就是天份的最主要要素之一吗？
: 但王巅峰时 先发也是155在飙的啊
: 难道就是因为个性太低调，始终没有什么太具话题的历程心路(
: 19胜那些后来的成就就别提了)
: 最后陈伟殷就更不用提了，在这里几乎都被下隐身术了
曹锦辉,郭泓志,王建民的天份都很好啦
只是曹锦辉跟郭泓志比王又再好一点
郭泓志的天份不用讲了
光他在小联盟第一场投球的十个打者里就三振七个
只有两个人能摸到球打成软弱无力滚地球就可以知道他有健康时多威
道奇的亚洲事务部助理Scott Akasaki当时看他比赛
结束就打电话给他爸 (他爸最爱的球员是Sandy Koufax)
"爸,我知道我从没看过Sandy Koufax,但我看到了郭泓志"
不过这场最后一球 郭的韧带就断了....
当然 郭后来屠杀大联盟的武器跟他一开始的武器一样 都是一颗很杀的速球
http://www.baseballamerica.com/statistics/players/cards/27087
http://www.baseballamerica.com/online/leagues/mlb/rockies/02top10.html
曹锦辉在2000球季结束时是BA名列第15的新秀
2001刚受伤那时的评语是
Strengths: Tsao has the makings of a dominant power pitcher. He has a
legitimate mid-90s fastball and an excellent slider he can throw anytime in
the count. He has a good feel for pitching, particularly at such a young age.
Tsao also has shown an ability to throw strikes and is a quick study.
优点 曹有很不错的95mile左右速球跟很杀的滑球 具备当power pitcher的条件
Weaknesses: Obviously, missing the bulk of last season and not being expected
to be ready at the start of 2001 will rob Tsao of what he needs most:
experience. He was so dominant in his native Taiwan that he is still learning
about the demands of success in the big leagues. The work required to come
back from Tommy John surgery should give him an idea of the effort involved.
There’s a strong feeling that his lack of an offseason throwing program set
the stage for his elbow problem. Tsao has such a good
slider that at times he’ll forget to use his fastball. He did begin throwing
a two-seam fastball early last year to give hitters a different look.
缺点是刚受伤要复原,还有滑球太杀有时会忘记用他的速球
王建民
http://www.baseballamerica.com/statistics/players/cards/27557
从来没入选BA百大新秀
最好的排名是2002在洋基自家农场排第七
他在2004刚学会sinker的评语是这样
The most likely cause for the increase in hits allowed is a lack of command
over his fastball and/or breaking pitches. Wang is a command pitcher and ,
without blazing stuff, he'll live and die by his control. Wang features four
good pitches, a simple and fluid delivery, and a calm demeanor that is a rare
bonus for a player his age. His fastball generally tops out at around 95 mph,
but he tends to range closer to the low 90s. He also features a good splitter
and good slider.The solid mechanics should help him avoid future injury,but as
was stated before, he seems to continue to be an injury risk.
王是控球型投手,没有令人惊艳的球种,靠控球吃饭
他的速球可以到95mile 但大部份在low 90
他有好的指叉跟滑球,他的投球机制让他有避免受伤的机会
但他好像还是有高受伤的风险
看到王建民以前的球探报告 你只会想说这谁呀
把名字遮住不看这完全跟当初2005~2009在大联盟的王建民是完全不同人啊
总之在小联盟前期这三人是这样的
曹:速球球威不错 滑球很杀
郭:速球超杀 滑球不错
王:速球不错 指叉不错 滑球不错 控球不错
曹跟郭这两个都有一种power pitch和一个不错的球种的投手
只要再练出一种average的球种就可以变成ace级的投手
而王缺乏一种power pitch一般预估的天花板是比其他两人低的
谁知道他忽然在2A练出power pitch..
不过郭泓志如果健康的话应该屠杀大联盟就是..